Had the IIM Calcutta interview and group discussion today. Was shortlisted only for the PGDCM program. Most present were in both or only for PGDM, I along with one other were the only ones for the exclusively PGDCM program.
The people shortlisted for both needed to give two personal interviews and only one GD. My centre was at IIM Calcutta. Was in the morning session, starting 9:30 am. No girls at all! Since the center was at IIM Calcutta, it seemed too familiar territory for them. The profs were completely in their informals. There were 3 profs in our panel.
We were asked to submit our originals and the form for verification. Did that, since I was the first in our group. It seemed to be great to have it done and then leave soon. People were strangely silent and there didn't seem to be a lot of interaction, contrary to the case of IIM Bangalore and IIM Kozhikode interview.
The GD process:
Started with the GD for all the PGDCM shortlisted candidates. There were 9 in our group. We were called in one at a time from the list. I was the first one, so sat in the corner. Now this GD was different in that it wasn't in a hotel room, so the chairs were all arranged in a semi-circle and the three profs were sitting quite away. We were first told the "process" of the GD. We would be given a topic for discussion and a couple of minutes to think about it. Then there would be a 10 minute discussion. Then they said they would call out names in a random order and that person would have to speak for 1 minute everything that he hasn't spoken or a GD summary or anything. They didn't seem to look for anything in specific, coz they said initially about points you didn't get a chance to speak and later said you could also summarize.
The topic of the GD was "MBAs do not make good business leaders". Initial reaction was obviously that of shock! They didn't give us any paper to write on; then one person asked for a piece of paper and we were all given a leaf out of a notepad. No desk to write upon though!
Anyway, they said 'now you may st...' and one fellow began already. Typical coaching center brainwashing :D - start the GD and you are halfway through mentality. Anyway he said something. I was the fourth or fifth speaker.
One good thing for me in the GD was that I wasn't cut in between by anyone, and my voice seemed to be loud enough, a big improvement personally from the IIM Bangalore interview. I did come in a few times when everyone began speaking, but after a couple of seconds it was just me ... did feel good :P
Anyway, the discussion went on, not very good on the basis of the points proposed, which is similar to the IIM Bangalore and IIM Kozikode GDs as well. My performance seemed decently fine in terms of points as well as the total time for discussion.
One person had done this 'OK wait you don't speak, let him speak' thing once, but seemed almost legitimate as that guy had really not spoken once!
I didn't notice the time as usual, they said stop sometime soon. Then they said they would be calling out the names for them to speak for 1 minute. They started with the guy who hardly spoke, and they remarked that as well when they asked him to speak. For the next 4, it seemed to follow the order of going about those who spoke the least to those who were more active. This changed for the 5th person whom I thought must have been considered the best. No idea though.
I was the second last. Did give my viewpoint as well as a summary in the direction that I was talking about. No idea whether I spoke for 1 minute, but was fluent enough. They were cutting short people who exceeded their time, but they didn't do that for me, so I guess it would have been less than a minute.
The PI experience:
The three profs were sitting at the same place; a chair was placed about 10 feet from them! I didn't know whether to sit there or drag it front, so I just stood there. They signalled me to sit. I had to deliberately increase my volume so they could hear me. They did get whatever I was trying to say, though I didn't understand them a couple of times!
The three of them seemed to ask questions randomly in a random order on random topics. So I wouldn't remember them as questions from P1, P2 or P3. Also, since the questions were random mostly, I might err on the order in which they were asked.
So here it goes ...
(SK is me, P is a prof)
SK: Wishes them. Is signalled to sit on a chair 10 feet away from his interviewers. Fears it might be a stress interview.
P: So tell me something about yourself.
SK: tells about background, family, hobbies.
P: So you are coming from Guwahati.
SK: Yes sir.
P: So tell me why is the north east technologically backward.
SK: blah blah about their reluctance to adapt to new technologies and them feeling threatened by the change.
P: So you think it is all in the mindset?
SK: Yes sir.
P: How should the situation be improved?
SK: blah blah about how the government should employ more people in the local industries like oil.
P: So is it the government's prime responsibility to take care of industrialization?
SK: It is one of the main responsibilities of the government.
P: But that's where the concept of private firms comes in. Look at Gujrat, most of the industries are privately run.
SK: Sir private firms have their restrictions, like they cannot be socially inclusive etc etc and some blah blah.
P: Ok
P: So you play chess?
SK: Yes sir
P: Have you played at any level
SK: Just at the hostel level :P (should have said at the insti level at least!)
P: So tell me there was this thing about Deep Blue, the chess computer. But there haven't been many thereafter. Why is it so difficult to make one?
SK: The number of combinations of moves get increasingly large.
P: Do you know how large? A number?
SK: Not sure sir, but in billions. In addition, it is not just the next move, but a whole strategy that needs to be thought over, which may go well beyond the next move.
P: So how many opening moves are possible?
SK: (thinks) 12
P: Are you sure?
SK: (realizes he is grossly mistaken! Takes a few seconds more and says) 20, for the first move of white.
P: How did you arrive at that?
SK: 8 pawns, either one or two steps ahead = 16, two positions for each knight = 4, so total 20.
P: Ok
P: Do you follow sports?
SK: Not that much sir!!
P: So are you aware of everything happening around?
SK: I am reasonably well aware sir
P: So what do you understand by globalization? What comes to your mind when I say globalization?
SK: (thinks about Appadurai's handout in HSS :P decides its a bad idea!!) Sir it is the opening up of markets and an influx of the Western capitalist economies to the rest of the world; and try to explain and elaborate on it.
P: (Doesn't look very convinced) Can you tell me in a sentence
SK: Sir it the exchange of social, cultural and economic ties across the countries (or something like that!)
P: So it is not just about the economy?
SK: No sir.
P: (looks convinced) Ok
P: So do you follow the economic news? Do you read the Economic Times
SK: Sir I am reasonably well aware of events.
P: So what is ERP?
SK: No idea sir :D
P: Have you ever heard the term ERP(it was ERP or EPR, not sure :P )?
SK: Never sir
P: Not even when you are browsing through the news?
SK: NO sir!!
P: Didn't you read it in mechanical engineering?
SK: No sir
P: Didn't you have any courses on the use of information technology in industries, supply chain management etc.?
SK: No sir!
P: So what did you read in mechanical engineering?
SK: Fluid mechanics, solid mechanics, materials, thermodynamics etc :P
P: So you know about various turbines? What are the types?
SK: Sir basically two types - axial and radial!
P: No there are the ones with low head, medium head and large head right?
SK: (pretends to think!) I am not aware of their names sir!
P: Ok
P: Have you worked on a CNC?
SK: Yes sir, we had an assignment on it.
P: So what are its advantages over conventional lathe?
SK: blah blah about precision, accuracy and mass production.
P: So why do they still use conventional lathes?
SK: blah blah about ease of modification and cost.
P: So do they still use manual lathes in foreign countries?
SK: Yes sir.
(should have diverted the discussion towards Finland intern, like I did in the IIM Bangalore interview, but didn't!)
P: So you are one of the few candidates who have applied only to the PGDCM program. Why is that?
SK: I wasn't shortlisted for the PGDM program.
P: (Some talk among themselves) Ok.
P: So do you know about the PGDCM program? Have you gone through the course structure?
SK: I have seen the outline sir.
P: So are you at all interested in it?
SK: Yes sir very much :D In fact I am good in programming, won the google programming contest and also a game programming event. I am good at the logic part of it.
P: So you have to find whether a number is prime or not. How will you do it.
SK: Check till root (N)
P: Why root N?
SK: Because any factor above root (N) will have a lesser factor too.
P: Ok fine, but still it is a lot of work for big numbers. Can you think of something more efficient.
SK: (thinks) Talk about Fermat's little theorem. This guy doesn't know it!
P: So what is it? a power what? what is a? will this work? some nonsense blabbar.
SK: This was an alternative when multiplication is cheap, I cannot think of anything else.
P: Ok.
P: So you like mathematics?
SK: Yes sir.
P: Which area?
SK: Number theory!
P: What is a rational number?
SK: Which can be expressed as p/q where p,q are integers. (Didn't say about q being positive! )
P: So can you tell me a number that isn't rational?
SK: pi
P: Something simpler?!
SK: root 2! :D
P: So can you prove that root 2 isn't rational?
SK: (thinks for a couple of seconds) Yes sir, I think I can.
P: Take the pen, directs me to the board, and asks me to use it.
SK: Take a minute and prove it.
P: (Convinced) OK
P: What is this course on Critical Thinking that you have taken?
SK: It is a philosophy course sir.
P: You have taken another course as well on philosophy right?
SK: Yes sir I like it very much :D
P: So can you tell me some differences between oriental and western philosophies??
SK: blah blah about soul, karma etc. (Should have talked about how religion and philosophy are so mixed and integral in eastern philosophies but completely the opposite for western philosophies. )
P: Can you name any 3 western philosophers?
SK: (sudden mind blank!) Descartes, Sartre (?!) ... ... (thinks) Plato, Aristotle!
P: Ok.
P: So you have heard this term "Meltdown" recently?
SK: Yes sir.
P: What does it mean?
SK: some blah blah about breakdown of financial institutions and the current economic system as we know it.
P: How did it start?
SK: Started with the US sub-prime mortgage crisis.
P: What is sub prime?
SK: Those customers who do not have adequate means to pay back.
P: Is that what is sub-prime?
SK: Sir banks have a credit history of customers, and those that do not have good credit history are sub-prime.
P: (not very convinced) Hmm ok.
P: (to others asking them if they had anything else to ask. None had) Ok so you may go.
SK: Thank you sirs.
P: (while I was collecting my file) So what other IIM calls do you have?
SK: IIM Kozikode, IIM Lucknow, IIM Ahmedabad. (didn't tell him Bangalore, don't know why!)
P: Is this your first interview?
SK: No sir, I am already done with Kozikode
P: Ok
SK: Thank you sir !
Showing posts with label IIM. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IIM. Show all posts
Monday, March 9, 2009
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
IIM Bangalore GD/PI experience on 24th February 2009
Had my IIM Bangalore interview and GD today, 24th Feb 09 at Kolkata. The venue was the same - Kelinworth Hotel. My slot was the morning 9:00 am slot.
There were two panels. Each panel was supposed to have 8 candidates, but two were absent? :eek: ... and two were absent even from the other panel! So in all, we were 6 of us. One girl, rest boys. The interview panel had a lady prof and a male prof. Dress sense of profs was formal, unlike for the IIM Kozhikode interview! My panel had one guy from Shillong, one guy from Sikkim and me from Guwahati! :D I was 3rd in my panel.
The GD experience:
Started off with a GD. Called the names and we were made to sit in order, just like for IIM Kozhikode interview. They told us we would be given a topic, given 5 minutes to think, 15 minutes to discuss and 5-10 minutes to write a summary. They weren't strict at all with the timings, and when some people didn't finish their summary writing in time, they announced that those who had finished may leave, rest may take more time! Anyway, I did finish it in time :)
We were strangely allowed to keep the GD sheet with ourselves. This was not the case with the other panel, where the sheets were taken away. This is the exact topic of the GD:
In recent times, the government has imposed restrictions on nightlife. All pubs and nightclubs have to be shut by 11:30 and discotheques are not allowed. The government and the police contend that imposing early closing hours has helped reduce crime rates and drunken driving. The people visiting pubs and nightclubs say that they are not criminals and drunk driving is unlikely to stop unless sliquor shops are closed down. They further point out that by putting curbs on nightlife, the government risks criminalizing fairly harmless activity. Anyway if this argument is carried to its logical conclusion then it would be like arguing that all travel should be stopped because any travel raises the risk of accident. They also argue that drinking and dancing is not illegal and the government is imposing unncessary restrictions. In reply some people argue that it is immoral to drink and dance and 11:30 at night is late enough. The supporters contend that they work long hours often past 11 p.m. and if they feel the urge to go for a drink they should be allowed to. The arguments rage on.
Where do you stand in this debate?
The GD had absolutely no high noise levels and was very civil. My performance wasn't as good as it could/should have been, but wasn't bad either. Did come up with a couple of good points but overall speaking time was quite less, and should have been much more. Later the first question in my interview was my opinion on the topic of the GD!
Anyway, IIM Bangalore claims that it gives only 5% weightage to the GD, 5% to the summary and another 5% to the summary style! The only problem is there are very less freshers called for the GD/PI process, and so might be slightly difficult to make it finally. However, overall the GD was satisfactory though could have been better.
The interview experience:
The interview lasted for about 12-15 minutes. People coming out were quite happy with their performance. There was no stress at all. The interview was very casual in nature, absolutely no technical questions and no questions on general knowledge/economics etc too! Was just like a conversation across the table.
The lady prof was asking all the questions and the other prof was going through the certificates. Since it was more like a conversation and questions raised from where I led the discussion to, I don't think the experience might help people much! But anyway, here it is - the questions may not be in order
(LP = lady prof, MP = male prof, SK = me)
LP: So what do you think about the GD
SK: (starts off with a summary type, where I say 'the group felt that...')
LP: No, tell me your views on the topic
SK: blah blah in partial support of nightlife and clubs with sensible restrictions etc. Mention somewhere that crime isn't exactly proportional to nightlife, as can be seen in foreign countries. Also say that there should be regular alcohol checks, as in foreign countries perhaps.
LP: So can you tell me one country where such checks are done?
SK: When I went to Finland (:D :P) I did see an active nightlife and also the crime rate is one of the least in the world
LP: So why do you think crime rate is less there? Are Indians more unruly?
SK: blah blah about they being rich
LP: Ok.
LP: So you are in your final year
SK: Yes ma'am
LP: So are you placed?
SK: Yes ma'am,.
LP: So where will you be placed?
SK: Didn't get the final offer letter, no idea!
LP: So what will you be joining as? What will be your role?
LP, SK: (blah blah about it, some desultory chit chat ! )
MP: So I will ask you a standard question, you may give me a standard answer!
SK: :O :O :O
MP: So why do you want to do an MBA?
SK: blah blah about how it would make me more useful and complement my technical background.
MP: (not convinced, some other questions)
SK: Sir I was actively involved with organizing my technical festival ....
MP: OK OK now THAT is a standard answer. No need to elaborate :D I'll cancel this question!
SK: (smiles!)
MP: So you have been to Finland right?
SK: Yes sir
MP: What is the most common drink there?
SK: (:O) I am not very sure, but Finlandia vodka is very famous! :D
MP, SK: (some chit chat about it)
MP,SK: (chit chat about drinking at IITs, drugs(!), ragging, smoking, why I don't drink, peer groups, how IITs much have changed(!) etc. etc. )
LP: So what are your hobbies?
SK: Playing chess, writing poems and short essays
LP: What do you write on?
SK: Contemporary topics, philosophy and religion
LP: What was the last thing you wrote about?
SK, LP, MP: (a whole lot of chit chat about religion, Hinduism, western influence, writing at IIT, and blah blah blah!!)
LP: Have you gotten your work published in say newspapers or magazines?
SK: No ma'am, just the college maganizes and newsletters.
LP: So you mentioned in your SOP about your internship at IISc. Did you visit IIM Bangalore then?
SK: (:D :O :P) No ma'am!
LP: So you didn't have MBA on your mind then?
SK: Not exactly ma'am.
LP: So when did you have those plans?
SK: After coming back!! ( :D) I was involved with my technical festival, gotten a first hand feel of management blah blah
LP: So do you think organizing a fest is equivalent to a career in management?
SK: Not really ma'am, but blah blah about how MBA would help me a lot to apply my technical 'expertise' and make informed decisions and blah blah
LP: Ok, thank you for your time
SK: Thank you ma'am, thank you sir. (leaves)
There were two panels. Each panel was supposed to have 8 candidates, but two were absent? :eek: ... and two were absent even from the other panel! So in all, we were 6 of us. One girl, rest boys. The interview panel had a lady prof and a male prof. Dress sense of profs was formal, unlike for the IIM Kozhikode interview! My panel had one guy from Shillong, one guy from Sikkim and me from Guwahati! :D I was 3rd in my panel.
The GD experience:
Started off with a GD. Called the names and we were made to sit in order, just like for IIM Kozhikode interview. They told us we would be given a topic, given 5 minutes to think, 15 minutes to discuss and 5-10 minutes to write a summary. They weren't strict at all with the timings, and when some people didn't finish their summary writing in time, they announced that those who had finished may leave, rest may take more time! Anyway, I did finish it in time :)
We were strangely allowed to keep the GD sheet with ourselves. This was not the case with the other panel, where the sheets were taken away. This is the exact topic of the GD:
In recent times, the government has imposed restrictions on nightlife. All pubs and nightclubs have to be shut by 11:30 and discotheques are not allowed. The government and the police contend that imposing early closing hours has helped reduce crime rates and drunken driving. The people visiting pubs and nightclubs say that they are not criminals and drunk driving is unlikely to stop unless sliquor shops are closed down. They further point out that by putting curbs on nightlife, the government risks criminalizing fairly harmless activity. Anyway if this argument is carried to its logical conclusion then it would be like arguing that all travel should be stopped because any travel raises the risk of accident. They also argue that drinking and dancing is not illegal and the government is imposing unncessary restrictions. In reply some people argue that it is immoral to drink and dance and 11:30 at night is late enough. The supporters contend that they work long hours often past 11 p.m. and if they feel the urge to go for a drink they should be allowed to. The arguments rage on.
Where do you stand in this debate?
The GD had absolutely no high noise levels and was very civil. My performance wasn't as good as it could/should have been, but wasn't bad either. Did come up with a couple of good points but overall speaking time was quite less, and should have been much more. Later the first question in my interview was my opinion on the topic of the GD!
Anyway, IIM Bangalore claims that it gives only 5% weightage to the GD, 5% to the summary and another 5% to the summary style! The only problem is there are very less freshers called for the GD/PI process, and so might be slightly difficult to make it finally. However, overall the GD was satisfactory though could have been better.
The interview experience:
The interview lasted for about 12-15 minutes. People coming out were quite happy with their performance. There was no stress at all. The interview was very casual in nature, absolutely no technical questions and no questions on general knowledge/economics etc too! Was just like a conversation across the table.
The lady prof was asking all the questions and the other prof was going through the certificates. Since it was more like a conversation and questions raised from where I led the discussion to, I don't think the experience might help people much! But anyway, here it is - the questions may not be in order
(LP = lady prof, MP = male prof, SK = me)
LP: So what do you think about the GD
SK: (starts off with a summary type, where I say 'the group felt that...')
LP: No, tell me your views on the topic
SK: blah blah in partial support of nightlife and clubs with sensible restrictions etc. Mention somewhere that crime isn't exactly proportional to nightlife, as can be seen in foreign countries. Also say that there should be regular alcohol checks, as in foreign countries perhaps.
LP: So can you tell me one country where such checks are done?
SK: When I went to Finland (:D :P) I did see an active nightlife and also the crime rate is one of the least in the world
LP: So why do you think crime rate is less there? Are Indians more unruly?
SK: blah blah about they being rich
LP: Ok.
LP: So you are in your final year
SK: Yes ma'am
LP: So are you placed?
SK: Yes ma'am,.
LP: So where will you be placed?
SK: Didn't get the final offer letter, no idea!
LP: So what will you be joining as? What will be your role?
LP, SK: (blah blah about it, some desultory chit chat ! )
MP: So I will ask you a standard question, you may give me a standard answer!
SK: :O :O :O
MP: So why do you want to do an MBA?
SK: blah blah about how it would make me more useful and complement my technical background.
MP: (not convinced, some other questions)
SK: Sir I was actively involved with organizing my technical festival ....
MP: OK OK now THAT is a standard answer. No need to elaborate :D I'll cancel this question!
SK: (smiles!)
MP: So you have been to Finland right?
SK: Yes sir
MP: What is the most common drink there?
SK: (:O) I am not very sure, but Finlandia vodka is very famous! :D
MP, SK: (some chit chat about it)
MP,SK: (chit chat about drinking at IITs, drugs(!), ragging, smoking, why I don't drink, peer groups, how IITs much have changed(!) etc. etc. )
LP: So what are your hobbies?
SK: Playing chess, writing poems and short essays
LP: What do you write on?
SK: Contemporary topics, philosophy and religion
LP: What was the last thing you wrote about?
SK, LP, MP: (a whole lot of chit chat about religion, Hinduism, western influence, writing at IIT, and blah blah blah!!)
LP: Have you gotten your work published in say newspapers or magazines?
SK: No ma'am, just the college maganizes and newsletters.
LP: So you mentioned in your SOP about your internship at IISc. Did you visit IIM Bangalore then?
SK: (:D :O :P) No ma'am!
LP: So you didn't have MBA on your mind then?
SK: Not exactly ma'am.
LP: So when did you have those plans?
SK: After coming back!! ( :D) I was involved with my technical festival, gotten a first hand feel of management blah blah
LP: So do you think organizing a fest is equivalent to a career in management?
SK: Not really ma'am, but blah blah about how MBA would help me a lot to apply my technical 'expertise' and make informed decisions and blah blah
LP: Ok, thank you for your time
SK: Thank you ma'am, thank you sir. (leaves)
Monday, February 9, 2009
IIM Kozhikode Interview Experience on 9th February 2009
IIMK GD/PI experience
----------------------------------
Had the GD/PI of IIM Kozikode at 9:00 am on Monday, Feb. 9th. Venue was Kelinworth Hotel in Kolkata. Hotel was pretty good, lots of foreigners too - guess its 3 star but not sure. Reached the centre by 8:15 am; decided it was too early, took a stroll outside for 10 minutes and went in. Some chairs to sit in the open, so sat there. 6 others had already arrived. A few others had come later. By 8:45 we were asked to go inside and be seated. About 18-20 people were present. 3 were girls ;)
4 people arrived, we figured they would be the interview/GD panel. Not dressed formally at all. At least two thought an "in-shirt" would do no harm! For the first panel, they called out the names. One person was absent. My name was called in second last. Total of 9 in my panel. We were seated as they called our names, so I was in the last but one chair - next to the corner one. Was getting pretty tensed already - I still just HATE GDs!
There was a paper in front of us, covered. We were instructed to read it and jot down any points for 5 minutes on the same sheet of paper (wonder why there was a pad present too!) and would then be given 15 minutes for the discussion.
The case was about how some Janavi was called Jane in her office, worked when her family and friends slept and thinks the Indian Independence day is on 4th July (?!) and the question was whether the IT/BPO industry had destroyed a whole generation of Indians. I had no clue whether to support or go against it (as usual!) ; didn't write down any 'points' for discussion since I never start the GD anyway! Just wanted to go with the flow. Was already getting tenser! My first impression for the group was they are not as dominant as say the group in IMS or the all 'charged' up group at IITG thanks to VC! (thanks again to him for the impression I carry about GDs!!) It did prove right in the end.
The case started with someone trying to define the problem. As usual it sounded dumb. As usual, three guys then tried to 'pitch in'. As usual, I was clueless! Didn't speak for about 2-3 minutes initially at all. Then tried to say something, got cut down by the 'market'. Remembered what Ankit said - if needed raise your voice, keep continuing what you are saying. Went for it. Was surprised the group became silent to listen to me, though my points weren't the best or even as good as I would have liked them to be. Still, it felt nice. Then on, I periodically kept pitching in and people progressively paid more attention. The one girl in our group never got a chance to speak but kept trying. Out of frustration sometime in the middle when she was cut by someone, she went on a recorded tape recorded mode - 'May I May I May I' and then the whole group became silent. Was fun to watch.
Overall GD was far better than my expectations, at least in terms of the number of times or minutes that I spoke for. In terms of time, I would be in the top 3-4. Still, was a good experience. The moderators seemed quite 'warm' and un-intimidating.
The interview was to be in the same order. Sat with 3 others - a guy Sourabh from NIT Nagpur who stayed in Guwahati for 14 years, another guy with 4-5 years experience in some Japanese company and the girl in our group - Madhuri from Patna. Sourabh had gotten all calls (97 odd percentile). Chit-chatted for quite some time about a variety of topics including some GK/current affairs. Didn't get anywhere near tensed during this time, all to be changed soon.
Sourabh was the first to go in and come out. Immediately after was Madhuri. Then some guy and then me. Both Sourabh and Madhuri said it was quite OK types, not a stress interview. The others from the second panel said it was a proper stress interview, quite unhappy about it.
Got quite tensed in the interview initially for about 5 minutes, then it was all cool. Interview had two people, P1 and P2. P1 asked mostly technical, P2 was more into other stuff. Both were very cool about it all. SK is me, Siddharth Kalla :) The other group had questions like explain refrigeration etc,which I could never answer!!
SK: Good afternoon sirs
P1: Please have a seat. Please hand over the form and the certificates.
SK: [does as told]
P1: Ok so Mr. Siddharth Kalla, you from IIT Guwahati right?
P2: [meanwhile looks at my form]
SK: Yes sir
P1: Tell me something about yourself
SK: [realizes he wasn't prepared for this. How DUMB!]
SK: I am Siddharth Kalla from final year Mechanical Engineering from IIT Guwahati
P1: [Nods his head as if telling me he already knows it all and wants something 'more']
SK: Tell him my hobbies, my final year B.Tech project (?!) and about my family background.
P1: So you are Mechanical Engineering. Do you know about engines, heat exhangers and thermodynamics?
SK: [this is the worst part! Thats one area I know just nothing of! ]
SK: I know the fundamentals, we had the basics of it in a course (No way I was going to tell him how many courses we actually had!!)
[now the best part he asks me the real basics. happy with it]
P1: So what is the zeroth law of thermodynamics?
SK: Tell him about thermal equilibrium. Try to act 'smart' and tell him thats the principle a thermometer works on.
P1: So what is the principle in a thermometer.
SK: For a mercury in glass thermometer, it is expansion on heating.
P1: OK so any other methods for measuring the temperature?
SK: [thinks for a while] Pressure of a gas - when heated, the pressure increases.
P1: [nods] So anything else?
SK: [thinks again for a while longer] Resistance changes with temperature, so that can be measured.
P1: Nods more emphatically. So any others?
SK: [thinks way too longer! - how could I forget thermocouples!]
P1: OK, so what is the first law of thermodynamics?
SK: Sir, basically conservation of energy.
P1: So what is the second law of thermodynamics?
SK: Sir it basically [word used for the second time - to be avoided in future!!] says that the entropy of the universe always increases.
P1: [Gets WIDE EYED. I should have told about how heat--> work can never be 100% efficient or something about heat engines and source-sink stuff]
P1: What is entropy?
SK: It is a measure of disorderness in a system.
P1: So why should it always increase?
SK: Thats how things are - there can be no proof for it, it is just like the conservation of energy - it cannot be proved but found to be true in all cases.
P1: Okkk [seems semi-convinced]
P1: So why are the laws named as zeroth, first and second instead of first, second and third?
SK: Sir the first law was stated earlier and then the zeroth law.
P1: Are you sure?
SK: Yes sir [remember reading it somewhere, don't know where!] the first law was stated first, then the zeroth law was identified and found to be more fundamental than the first law. So it was called the zeroth law.
P1: Ok so what is a heat exchanger?
SK: [thinks for a while] It is basically (?!) for heat exchange.
P1: Heat exchange where?
SK: Between a hot fluid and cold fluid.
P1: Ok so what are the different modes of heat transfer?
SK: Conduction, convection and radiation.
P1: What is conduction.
SK: [explains about molecular vibrations etc.]
P1: Does it always occur naturally or can it be forced?
SK: [thinks for a while] I am not sure if it can be forced, but convection can be forced.
P1: So in a heat exchanger, which is the most dominant mode of heat transfer?
SK: Sir convection is most dominant
P1 : Ok... [seems convinced]
SK: [why does he say this?!] but conduction is also important
P1: CONDUCTION?
SK: [tells hims about the surface interface where conduction takes place blah blah blah]
P1: So why is there conduction and convection, why not just conduction?
SK: Tell him that it is convenient, and it occurs regularly in nature, like land breeze, sea breeze. Also tell him its something like electricity and magnetism that we study separately though they are unified. No visible reaction from him.
P1: So how many types of heat exchangers are there?
SK: Parallel and counter parallel.
P1: What are they?
SK: [explains]
P1: Any other types?
SK: [thinks] None that I know of
P1: Ok, so which one is more effective?
SK: Counter parallel?
P1: Why is it so, when it is the same cross sectional area.
SK: [Tries to explain, not convinced. Leaves it.]
Turns to P2.
P2: So have you learned any managerial skills during your college study?
SK: Fundae about organizational skills.
P2: Do you follow current affairs, politics, economics etc?
SK: To the basic level, yes sir. (Had no intention to take my chances!)
P2: So what is the latest happening?
SK: Gaza ... explains blah blah
P2: Anything in India?
SK: [begins to think!! OMG couldn't come up with anything - VERY BAD!]
P2: So what is GDP?
SK: Value of all the goods and services produced in a country.
P1: So is the renumeration of Sachin and Shahrukh added to the GDP?
SK: Sir I think so
P1: But they are not producing any goods?
SK: Sir they provide a service that people like to pay and watch.
P1: But that is already covered in the advertising.
SK: [didn't want to argue. pretend to think] I am not sure sir
P1: [smiles] OK
P1: [looks at P2, both nod]
P1: Thank you Mr. Siddharth.
SK: Look surprised(?!) I felt the interview was too short - later realized it was for 15 minutes -seemed like 5 minutes! I stand up to go and also wish them
P1: Are you surprised that the interview is over? (!?)
SK: [Smiles, thinks and says] Sir, A little bit yes sir. (very timidly!)
P1: [laughs!]
P1: Is this your first interview?
SK: Yes sir
P1: All the best to you
SK: Thank you sir!
----------------------------------
Had the GD/PI of IIM Kozikode at 9:00 am on Monday, Feb. 9th. Venue was Kelinworth Hotel in Kolkata. Hotel was pretty good, lots of foreigners too - guess its 3 star but not sure. Reached the centre by 8:15 am; decided it was too early, took a stroll outside for 10 minutes and went in. Some chairs to sit in the open, so sat there. 6 others had already arrived. A few others had come later. By 8:45 we were asked to go inside and be seated. About 18-20 people were present. 3 were girls ;)
4 people arrived, we figured they would be the interview/GD panel. Not dressed formally at all. At least two thought an "in-shirt" would do no harm! For the first panel, they called out the names. One person was absent. My name was called in second last. Total of 9 in my panel. We were seated as they called our names, so I was in the last but one chair - next to the corner one. Was getting pretty tensed already - I still just HATE GDs!
There was a paper in front of us, covered. We were instructed to read it and jot down any points for 5 minutes on the same sheet of paper (wonder why there was a pad present too!) and would then be given 15 minutes for the discussion.
The case was about how some Janavi was called Jane in her office, worked when her family and friends slept and thinks the Indian Independence day is on 4th July (?!) and the question was whether the IT/BPO industry had destroyed a whole generation of Indians. I had no clue whether to support or go against it (as usual!) ; didn't write down any 'points' for discussion since I never start the GD anyway! Just wanted to go with the flow. Was already getting tenser! My first impression for the group was they are not as dominant as say the group in IMS or the all 'charged' up group at IITG thanks to VC! (thanks again to him for the impression I carry about GDs!!) It did prove right in the end.
The case started with someone trying to define the problem. As usual it sounded dumb. As usual, three guys then tried to 'pitch in'. As usual, I was clueless! Didn't speak for about 2-3 minutes initially at all. Then tried to say something, got cut down by the 'market'. Remembered what Ankit said - if needed raise your voice, keep continuing what you are saying. Went for it. Was surprised the group became silent to listen to me, though my points weren't the best or even as good as I would have liked them to be. Still, it felt nice. Then on, I periodically kept pitching in and people progressively paid more attention. The one girl in our group never got a chance to speak but kept trying. Out of frustration sometime in the middle when she was cut by someone, she went on a recorded tape recorded mode - 'May I May I May I' and then the whole group became silent. Was fun to watch.
Overall GD was far better than my expectations, at least in terms of the number of times or minutes that I spoke for. In terms of time, I would be in the top 3-4. Still, was a good experience. The moderators seemed quite 'warm' and un-intimidating.
The interview was to be in the same order. Sat with 3 others - a guy Sourabh from NIT Nagpur who stayed in Guwahati for 14 years, another guy with 4-5 years experience in some Japanese company and the girl in our group - Madhuri from Patna. Sourabh had gotten all calls (97 odd percentile). Chit-chatted for quite some time about a variety of topics including some GK/current affairs. Didn't get anywhere near tensed during this time, all to be changed soon.
Sourabh was the first to go in and come out. Immediately after was Madhuri. Then some guy and then me. Both Sourabh and Madhuri said it was quite OK types, not a stress interview. The others from the second panel said it was a proper stress interview, quite unhappy about it.
Got quite tensed in the interview initially for about 5 minutes, then it was all cool. Interview had two people, P1 and P2. P1 asked mostly technical, P2 was more into other stuff. Both were very cool about it all. SK is me, Siddharth Kalla :) The other group had questions like explain refrigeration etc,which I could never answer!!
SK: Good afternoon sirs
P1: Please have a seat. Please hand over the form and the certificates.
SK: [does as told]
P1: Ok so Mr. Siddharth Kalla, you from IIT Guwahati right?
P2: [meanwhile looks at my form]
SK: Yes sir
P1: Tell me something about yourself
SK: [realizes he wasn't prepared for this. How DUMB!]
SK: I am Siddharth Kalla from final year Mechanical Engineering from IIT Guwahati
P1: [Nods his head as if telling me he already knows it all and wants something 'more']
SK: Tell him my hobbies, my final year B.Tech project (?!) and about my family background.
P1: So you are Mechanical Engineering. Do you know about engines, heat exhangers and thermodynamics?
SK: [this is the worst part! Thats one area I know just nothing of! ]
SK: I know the fundamentals, we had the basics of it in a course (No way I was going to tell him how many courses we actually had!!)
[now the best part he asks me the real basics. happy with it]
P1: So what is the zeroth law of thermodynamics?
SK: Tell him about thermal equilibrium. Try to act 'smart' and tell him thats the principle a thermometer works on.
P1: So what is the principle in a thermometer.
SK: For a mercury in glass thermometer, it is expansion on heating.
P1: OK so any other methods for measuring the temperature?
SK: [thinks for a while] Pressure of a gas - when heated, the pressure increases.
P1: [nods] So anything else?
SK: [thinks again for a while longer] Resistance changes with temperature, so that can be measured.
P1: Nods more emphatically. So any others?
SK: [thinks way too longer! - how could I forget thermocouples!]
P1: OK, so what is the first law of thermodynamics?
SK: Sir, basically conservation of energy.
P1: So what is the second law of thermodynamics?
SK: Sir it basically [word used for the second time - to be avoided in future!!] says that the entropy of the universe always increases.
P1: [Gets WIDE EYED. I should have told about how heat--> work can never be 100% efficient or something about heat engines and source-sink stuff]
P1: What is entropy?
SK: It is a measure of disorderness in a system.
P1: So why should it always increase?
SK: Thats how things are - there can be no proof for it, it is just like the conservation of energy - it cannot be proved but found to be true in all cases.
P1: Okkk [seems semi-convinced]
P1: So why are the laws named as zeroth, first and second instead of first, second and third?
SK: Sir the first law was stated earlier and then the zeroth law.
P1: Are you sure?
SK: Yes sir [remember reading it somewhere, don't know where!] the first law was stated first, then the zeroth law was identified and found to be more fundamental than the first law. So it was called the zeroth law.
P1: Ok so what is a heat exchanger?
SK: [thinks for a while] It is basically (?!) for heat exchange.
P1: Heat exchange where?
SK: Between a hot fluid and cold fluid.
P1: Ok so what are the different modes of heat transfer?
SK: Conduction, convection and radiation.
P1: What is conduction.
SK: [explains about molecular vibrations etc.]
P1: Does it always occur naturally or can it be forced?
SK: [thinks for a while] I am not sure if it can be forced, but convection can be forced.
P1: So in a heat exchanger, which is the most dominant mode of heat transfer?
SK: Sir convection is most dominant
P1 : Ok... [seems convinced]
SK: [why does he say this?!] but conduction is also important
P1: CONDUCTION?
SK: [tells hims about the surface interface where conduction takes place blah blah blah]
P1: So why is there conduction and convection, why not just conduction?
SK: Tell him that it is convenient, and it occurs regularly in nature, like land breeze, sea breeze. Also tell him its something like electricity and magnetism that we study separately though they are unified. No visible reaction from him.
P1: So how many types of heat exchangers are there?
SK: Parallel and counter parallel.
P1: What are they?
SK: [explains]
P1: Any other types?
SK: [thinks] None that I know of
P1: Ok, so which one is more effective?
SK: Counter parallel?
P1: Why is it so, when it is the same cross sectional area.
SK: [Tries to explain, not convinced. Leaves it.]
Turns to P2.
P2: So have you learned any managerial skills during your college study?
SK: Fundae about organizational skills.
P2: Do you follow current affairs, politics, economics etc?
SK: To the basic level, yes sir. (Had no intention to take my chances!)
P2: So what is the latest happening?
SK: Gaza ... explains blah blah
P2: Anything in India?
SK: [begins to think!! OMG couldn't come up with anything - VERY BAD!]
P2: So what is GDP?
SK: Value of all the goods and services produced in a country.
P1: So is the renumeration of Sachin and Shahrukh added to the GDP?
SK: Sir I think so
P1: But they are not producing any goods?
SK: Sir they provide a service that people like to pay and watch.
P1: But that is already covered in the advertising.
SK: [didn't want to argue. pretend to think] I am not sure sir
P1: [smiles] OK
P1: [looks at P2, both nod]
P1: Thank you Mr. Siddharth.
SK: Look surprised(?!) I felt the interview was too short - later realized it was for 15 minutes -seemed like 5 minutes! I stand up to go and also wish them
P1: Are you surprised that the interview is over? (!?)
SK: [Smiles, thinks and says] Sir, A little bit yes sir. (very timidly!)
P1: [laughs!]
P1: Is this your first interview?
SK: Yes sir
P1: All the best to you
SK: Thank you sir!
Saturday, February 7, 2009
What you are supposed to carry when you travel :)
It might sound like a funny post. Nevertheless, with so little time to plan things out, sometimes going directly from the classes or just after exams, I thought this would be a small quick reference to all the things that you need to take for your journey to the IIM interviews. Of course I might have missed something, you are more than welcome to point it out so that I can incorporate it into the list. Hope it helps at least a few (at least me!!)
The essentials:
1. Money!
2. Ticket
3. Call letter + form (if any)
4. Certificates, including CAT admit card, CAT score card, originals of undergraduation, 12th, 10th marksheets, originals of certificates of extra-curricular activities and any other certificates for activities mentioned in the form.
5. College id card, credit card (required at times for verification of booking of flight, if any)
6. Cell phone with a SIM that works (you may find this 'stupid' if you ain't from Guwahati!) and a charger
It always helps when you have some last moment questions about say your hobbies (like I did before my IIM Kozikode interview!) that you might wish to know by calling up a friend and asking him to google it up!
7. Address of the hotel, any booking details etc.
8. A couple of photos might come in handy
9. Some ask for the xerox copies of your marksheets, so make sure you have them.
10. A pen!
Dress:
You will need 1 or 2 formal shirt(s), pant(s), tie, belt, socks, shoes. Some also wear a coat, which I don't.
Personally I find it very inconvenient to wear formal clothes, especially shoes on informal occasions. When traveling by flight, I wear the formal shoes along with my informal dress, and carry my formal dress and a pair of slippers with me. I always travel only with a handbag, and all items do conveniently fit into it!
So when I go out or in my room, I would never have to wear the formals except during the interview/GD.
Misc:
1. Toothbrush
2. Toothpaste
3. Soap (many smaller hotels don't have it!)
4. Towel (it may come in handy. The towels I was given for my first stay weren't as clean as I would have liked them to be. A towel always comes in handy; remember Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy!)
5. Few old newspapers (again comes in handy to keep your clothes. The shelves given weren't very clean again and I didn't want to keep my formals directly on it. A few old newspapers/today's newspaper again always comes in handy)
6. Shoe polish/brush (If you wear your formal shoes during travel, it would be good to have them polished before the interview)
About shoe polish, I found quite a few cobblers on my way to the hotel, who would polish your shoes well. You might want to make use of this facility! However, I don't know anything about their timings etc. so it might be risky if you land in the evening and your interview is in the morning. Perhaps I'll ask them about their timings and update it here!
7. Shaving kit
Again, there are a few barber shops around, but it might be risky. If you are like Gunda, forget this ;)
8. Shampoo
Again this depends on you. I prefer a head bath on the night before the interview.
9. Pen
10. Watch
You can generally get all the above items from the shops around, but you may have to travel a bit and it might be risky if you don't get it.
The essentials:
1. Money!
2. Ticket
3. Call letter + form (if any)
4. Certificates, including CAT admit card, CAT score card, originals of undergraduation, 12th, 10th marksheets, originals of certificates of extra-curricular activities and any other certificates for activities mentioned in the form.
5. College id card, credit card (required at times for verification of booking of flight, if any)
6. Cell phone with a SIM that works (you may find this 'stupid' if you ain't from Guwahati!) and a charger
It always helps when you have some last moment questions about say your hobbies (like I did before my IIM Kozikode interview!) that you might wish to know by calling up a friend and asking him to google it up!
7. Address of the hotel, any booking details etc.
8. A couple of photos might come in handy
9. Some ask for the xerox copies of your marksheets, so make sure you have them.
10. A pen!
Dress:
You will need 1 or 2 formal shirt(s), pant(s), tie, belt, socks, shoes. Some also wear a coat, which I don't.
Personally I find it very inconvenient to wear formal clothes, especially shoes on informal occasions. When traveling by flight, I wear the formal shoes along with my informal dress, and carry my formal dress and a pair of slippers with me. I always travel only with a handbag, and all items do conveniently fit into it!
So when I go out or in my room, I would never have to wear the formals except during the interview/GD.
Misc:
1. Toothbrush
2. Toothpaste
3. Soap (many smaller hotels don't have it!)
4. Towel (it may come in handy. The towels I was given for my first stay weren't as clean as I would have liked them to be. A towel always comes in handy; remember Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy!)
5. Few old newspapers (again comes in handy to keep your clothes. The shelves given weren't very clean again and I didn't want to keep my formals directly on it. A few old newspapers/today's newspaper again always comes in handy)
6. Shoe polish/brush (If you wear your formal shoes during travel, it would be good to have them polished before the interview)
About shoe polish, I found quite a few cobblers on my way to the hotel, who would polish your shoes well. You might want to make use of this facility! However, I don't know anything about their timings etc. so it might be risky if you land in the evening and your interview is in the morning. Perhaps I'll ask them about their timings and update it here!
7. Shaving kit
Again, there are a few barber shops around, but it might be risky. If you are like Gunda, forget this ;)
8. Shampoo
Again this depends on you. I prefer a head bath on the night before the interview.
9. Pen
10. Watch
You can generally get all the above items from the shops around, but you may have to travel a bit and it might be risky if you don't get it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)